The Passionate Pilgrim Begins

Welcome to “The Passionate Pilgrim”, the blog dedicated to all matters dealing with the Elizabethan and Jacobean stage.  As this blog is sponsored by Island Shakespeare Festival, it will focus initially on the plays being offered by them during their current season.

Unlike the standard academic introductions to As You Like It, which discuss plot, character, theme and so forth, I want to start with the very unusual circumstance of the so-called “Poets War” or “War of the Theaters” and the unique role this play performed in this dispute.

The standard academic history of this “war” asserts that it was ignited by John Marston in the play Histriomastix (1599), which included an attack on Ben Jonson, which supposedly censured Jonson “for being too dependent upon scholarship” (Bednarz, James P., Shakespeare and the Poets’ War, p. 91)

Ben Jonson (c. 1617), by Abraham Blyenberch; oil on canvas painting at the National Portrait Gallery, London
Ben Jonson (c. 1617), by Abraham Blyenberch; National Portrait Gallery, London

Jonson responded with Every Man Out of his Humour (1599), which included the clown character Clove, generally understood to be a stand in for Marston, who speaks “fustian” [ie: pompous, pretentious speech] in mimicry of Marston’s style. Insults are said to have followed in several plays, with other poets,  primarily Thomas Dekker, sometimes alone and sometimes in combination with Marston, throwing in their tuppence, until it all flamed out in 1602. Not atypically, there is some dispute about the sequence of these events, in particular whether or not Jonson’s satire of Marston actually preceded Histriomastix. In general, the academic version leaves Shakespeare out of the action.

The truth is a little different.

Title page of 1600 printing of "Every Man out of His Humour."
Title page of 1600 printing of “Every Man out of His Humour.” By Ben Jonson ( [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

If there ever was such a thing as a “Poets’ War,” itself being a characterization created by nineteenth century academicians, then it must fairly be said to have begun with Jonson’s very direct attacks on Shakespeare in Every Man Out of His Humour, where he mocks a character named Sogliardo for his acquisition of a herald whose motto is “Not Without Mustard.” This is universally understood as an unflattering reference to Shakespeare who had recently acquired a Heraldic emblem with the Latin motto “Non Sanz Drocit” which translates as “Not Without Right.”

Artist unknown, some say it may be William Shakespeare (College of Heralds, London) [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

Interestingly, Jonson’s previous play, Every Man In His Humour (1598) is the only play that actually records Shakespeare as an actor. He is listed in the 1616 printing of Jonson’s Folio as a principal commedian. Shakespeare is often listed with the Lord Chamberlain’s and later the King’s Company, but only as a shareholder or player, never as an actor and never in any printed script as an actor, not even in those credited to him.  All the academics who claim that Shakespeare played the Ghost of Hamlet, Amiens, etc., are just making it up (ie: Shakespeare is listed as a “player”, therefore he must have had a “part”, therefore I, Mr. Academic, based on nothing more than my personal preference, am going to cast him thus: post hoc ergo propter hoc at its best). There is, in fact, no evidence for Shakespeare playing any role onstage other than one written by Jonson.

After which, Jonson writes a play which mocks Shakespeare, and the Lord Chaimberlain’s Men, of which Shakespeare is a shareholder, immediately presents it.  Even Stephen Greenblatt admits how strange this must have been:

“As a member of the Lord Chamberlain’s Men, Will would have listened to this insult    again and again in rehearsal and in performance. He probably laughed uncomfortably- how else does one get through this kind of teasing?” Greenblatt, Stephen,  Will in the World, p. 80

All things considered, just as Greenblatt imagines that Shakespeare laughed it off, it is just as easy to imagine that by including Shakespeare in his Folio’s cast list Jonson was repeating the insult in print.

One might expect Shakespeare to respond to this as Marston appears to have done with an insult of his own. Or, as Greenblatt imagines, he might have laughed it off. What happened, however, is much more surprising.

Next: Will, Audrey and Touchstone

PeteHeadshotDr. Hodges holds a BFA in Acting from the University of Washington (class of ‘75), an M.A in Directing and a Ph. D. in Literature from The City Graduate Center of The City University of New York City, New York (1986 and 1992).  Doc Hodges (as he is sometimes known among his friends) is a 30 year veteran of the Wall Street wars, author and producer of more than a dozen plays, a novel, and a critical study of Sadakichi Hartmann’s plays.

2 thoughts on “The Passionate Pilgrim Begins

  1. This reminds me of moments where I trying and understand the hierarchy of characters from a show that’s been running for several seasons. The funny thing is this is almost representative of a rap battle or a twitter duel


    1. Absolutely! Thank you for bringing up this point. It reminds us of the Eazy-E and Ice Cube represented in “Straight Outta Compton.” Fascinating that artists have used their medium to call out their peers for so many centuries. It seems like a modern technique, but is illustrated here in a rich historical setting. If you have more thoughts on the subject, we would love to hear them!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s